Both hotels are endorsed by experts. On balance, Sugar Mill Hotel ranks significantly higher than Evening Star Villas. Sugar Mill Hotel comes in at 87 with accolades from 8 sources such as Lonely Planet, Travel + Leisure and Fodor's.
Sugar Mill Hotel
Apple Bay, Tortola
From $250 /night
- Free Internet
- Free Breakfast
- Laundry Service
"This inn combines a first-rate cuisine with intimate accommodations." Full review
"Though it's not a sprawling resort, the Sugar Mill Hotel has a Caribbean cachet that's hard to beat, and it's a favorite place to stay on Tortola." Full review
Travel + Leisure
"Children under 11 are not permitted from December 12 through April 14, but kids of all ages are welcome the rest of the year. (The hotel is closed August and September.)." Full review
"With an old sugar mill as its centerpiece, this hotel has 24 rooms, suites, and a villa scattered up the hillside at Apple Bay."
Show All Reviews
"The Sugar Mill can't miss when it comes to meeting (and often surpassing) guest expectations. Service is spot-on, and management concerns itself with all of the nuts-and-bolts details." Full review