Map

Colleen's At The Cannery vs Mama's Fish House

Both restaurants are recommended by expert writers. Overall, Mama's Fish House ranks slightly higher than Colleen's at the Cannery. Mama's Fish House comes in at #4 in Hawaii with accolades from 8 reviewers like Frommer's, Zagat and Lonely Planet.

Colleen's At The Cannery
Colleen's At The Cannery
8 / 10
810 Haiku Rd., Haiku, Maui, HI
From $0 /night
Gayot Gayot
12.0
"High-beamed ceilings, dark post-modern furniture, lush palm trees and large Art Deco mirrors create a glamorous yet unpretentious 1940s, old Hollywood vibe at this upcountry bistro." Full review
Fodor's Fodor's
"It's popular with locals for breakfast and lunch, but try it at dinner when the candles come out and it's time for martinis and fresh fish." Full review
DK Eyewitness DK Eyewitness
"Two miles off Hāna Highway in the small center of Ha‘ikū, this casual bistro is popular with local residents and visitors staying in north-shore rentals."
Zagat Zagat
4.2
"This all-day Haiku New American boasting black booths, a "laid-back" "Upcountry vibe" and "top-shelf" service delivers "gourmet meals at budget prices" to a "very local crowd." Full review
Frommer's Frommer's
"This go-to spot for Haiku residents serves an excellent breakfast, lunch, and dinner in a casual yet classy setting" Full review
Mama's Fish House
Mama's Fish House
8 / 10
799 Poho Pl, Paia, Maui, HI 96779-9708
From $25 /night
Zagat Zagat
4.8
""The freshest fish", "gracious" service and "tropical breezes make for an unforgettable experience" exult enthusiasts who find "heavenly bliss" at this "intimate" Pacific Rim seafooder." Full review
Gayot Gayot
13.0
"Mama'€™s has one of the best locations on the island: away from the resort areas, on the oceanfront in the small residential community of Kuau, on the Hana Highway." Full review
Fodor's Fodor's
"For almost four decades, Mama's has been the Maui destination for special occasions." Full review
DK Eyewitness DK Eyewitness
"This restaurant is not only famous because it has been at its oceanfront location for more than 25 years. The fresh fish dishes it serves are excellent and extremely expensive."
Condé Nast Traveler Condé Nast Traveler
Editor's Pick
"Unparalleled service and Hawaiian heyday vibe, all in one? You betcha." Full review
Show All Reviews