Map

Marea vs Gotham Restaurant

Both establishments are praised by travel writers. Overall, Marea ranks significantly higher than Gotham Bar & Grill. Marea is ranked #5 in New York City with recommendations from 16 sources such as Michelin Guide, Zagat and Village Voice.

Marea
Marea
9 / 10
240 Central Park South, New York, NY 10019
From $31 /night
Fodor's Fodor's
"Carefully sourced, meticulously prepared fish and seafood take center stage at this well-pedigreed restaurant." Full review
Travel + Leisure Travel + Leisure
"With fish sourced from the Mediterranean as well as worldwide waters, Marea ensures that the dining experience is enhanced by the best available ingredients." Full review
Zagat Zagat
""Memorable" is putting it mildly at chef Michael White's Columbus Circle "stunner", again voted NYC's No. 1 Italian thanks to "exquisite" seafood and pasta." Full review
BlackBook BlackBook
"Michael White goes for the trifecta after major scores with Convivio and Alto. Name means tide, high-end Italian seafood is the angle, with market-fresh fish from around the world."
DK Eyewitness DK Eyewitness
"This Italian seafood palace features a superb menu – with a location to match, situated as it is at the crossroads of Central Park South and Columbus Circle."
Show All Reviews
Gotham Restaurant
Gotham Restaurant
8 / 10
12 E 12th St, Frnt 1, New York, NY 10003
From $40 /night
Concierge Concierge
"Still feels like New York's most expertly run bustling restaurant."
Fodor's Fodor's
"This culinary landmark continues to focus on a foundation of simple, clean flavors to create transcendent preparations." Full review
Lonely Planet Lonely Planet
"Classically American like a crisp, just-pressed tuxedo, Gotham offers the finest fine-dining experience, with an assortment of perfect dishes and top-shelf cocktails." Full review
Travel + Leisure Travel + Leisure
"The high-ceilinged space is designed with oversize windows, white fabric chandeliers, and rotating artwork selected by the restaurant’s own curator." Full review
Zagat Zagat
""Still going strong" after 30 years." Full review
Show All Reviews