Minetta Tavern vs Gotham Restaurant
Both restaurants are rated highly by professional reviewers writing for major publications. Overall, Minetta Tavern scores marginally better than Gotham Bar & Grill. Minetta Tavern is ranked #23 in New York City with accolades from 17 reviews like New York Times, Michelin Guide and Village Voice.
Minetta Tavern
Show All Reviews
113 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012
From $31 /night
Concierge
"Despite the nightly star power, the menu—classic steak house meets neighborhood bistro—was designed with the recession in mind: not cheap, but reasonably priced."
Fodor's
"Try early and often to score reservations, so that you can sample creations like buttery trout meunière, bone marrow on toast, expertly aged steaks, and the celebrated Black Label burger."
Full review
Travel + Leisure
"This Parisian-style steakhouse serves a menu of French-American dishes, including roasted bone marrow with baguette soldiers and the signature Black Label Burger."
Full review
BlackBook
"Keith McNally, Riad Nasr, and Lee Hanson lord over rehab of historic resto into cool brasserie. Classic black and white tile look, retro in the best possible way."
DK Eyewitness
"This Italian bistro manages to be both casual and celebrity-friendly."
Gotham Restaurant
Show All Reviews
12 E 12th St, Frnt 1, New York, NY 10003
From $40 /night
Concierge
"Still feels like New York's most expertly run bustling restaurant."
Fodor's
"This culinary landmark continues to focus on a foundation of simple, clean flavors to create transcendent preparations."
Full review
Lonely Planet
"Classically American like a crisp, just-pressed tuxedo, Gotham offers the finest fine-dining experience, with an assortment of perfect dishes and top-shelf cocktails."
Full review
Travel + Leisure
"The high-ceilinged space is designed with oversize windows, white fabric chandeliers, and rotating artwork selected by the restaurant’s own curator."
Full review
Zagat
""Still going strong" after 30 years."
Full review