The Dutch vs Gotham Restaurant
Both The Dutch and Gotham Bar & Grill are highly recommended by professional reviewers. On balance, The Dutch ranks slightly higher than Gotham Bar & Grill. The Dutch scores 91 with endorsements from 16 reviews such as New York Times, Frommer's and Condé Nast Traveler.
The Dutch
Show All Reviews
131 Sullivan St, New York City, NY 10012
From $31 /night
Fodor's
"Andrew Carmellini's homage to American cuisine is really an encapsulation of recent food and dining trends... And it all works well at this SoHo restaurant."
Full review
Travel + Leisure
"Andrew Carmellini (also behind Tribeca’s buzzed-about Locanda Verde) hits all the right notes at this platonic ideal of the American bistro."
Full review
Zagat
"Chef Andrew Carmellini's "delish" riffs on American dishes draw "trendsetters" to this "fashionable" SoHo "winner"."
Full review
Rough Guide
Star
"Locally sourced produce and seasonal salads accompanying steaks, shellfish, hefty sandwiches, flavourful chilli, fried chicken and freshly baked pies."
Gayot
14.0
"Carmellini does his best work with the gamier meats like squab, which he serves with seared foie gras, or pecan duck with dirty rice."
Full review
Gotham Restaurant
Show All Reviews
12 E 12th St, Frnt 1, New York, NY 10003
From $40 /night
Concierge
"Still feels like New York's most expertly run bustling restaurant."
Fodor's
"This culinary landmark continues to focus on a foundation of simple, clean flavors to create transcendent preparations."
Full review
Lonely Planet
"Classically American like a crisp, just-pressed tuxedo, Gotham offers the finest fine-dining experience, with an assortment of perfect dishes and top-shelf cocktails."
Full review
Travel + Leisure
"The high-ceilinged space is designed with oversize windows, white fabric chandeliers, and rotating artwork selected by the restaurant’s own curator."
Full review
Zagat
""Still going strong" after 30 years."
Full review