City Diner
What the experts agree on
This authentic '50s diner nails the retro aesthetic with chrome, neon, and checkerboard floors. Order the famous milkshakes in metal cups, massive sandwiches, or all-day breakfast in a genuinely charming atmosphere.
“Midtown location is a ‘50s-style diner with red-topped bar stools and black and white checkerboard floor, milkshakes and gourmet sandwiches. Open daily 6 am–11 pm.”
– Where
"It’s American Graffiti inside with all-day breakfast and huge sandwiches like the Lenny’s Reuben." Full review
10.0
"A 50s-era starlet would feel right at home at the counter of this upscale diner." Full review
i
Choose fries, a green salad, soup or pineapple slaw (crisp and tangy) to round out an order.
"Chrome, neon, and vinyl create an atmosphere like a movie set, a theme fully realized through the friendly service and the milk shakes presented in metal mixing cups" Full review