A Stone's Throw AwayvsThe Reef at Atlantis
Both properties are rated very highly by professional reviewers. On balance, A Stone's Throw Away scores marginally higher than The Reef at Atlantis, Autograph Collection. A Stone's Throw Away scores 77 with praise from 2 reviewers such as Travel + Leisure, Lonely Planet.
A Stone's Throw Away
 Frommer's
 Travel + Leisure
 Frommer's
 Lonely Planet
Tropical Garden Road, Gambier Heights, Nassau SS5412, New Providence Island
From $269/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 - Laundy Room
 
 "- Reid Bramblett." Full review
 "You might as well call it the veranda hotel, because the old colonial mansion that is now A Stone’s Throw Away has an infinite balcony with stunning views that completely wraps the building." Full review
 "Rooms are modern homey, but island-style, with hardwood floors, rattan furnishings, king-sized beds, and Oriental rugs...there is a small, naturalistic pool with a bench under a waterfall ledge." Full review
Top choice
 "Getting to this extraordinary B&B requires climbing steep stone stairs through a cliff-side tunnel, after which you emerge in a tropical garden that’s like something out of a Merchant Ivory film." Full review
The Reef at Atlantis
 Travel + Leisure
 Gayot
 Jetsetter
 Condé Nast Traveler
1 Casino Dr, New Providence Island
From $399/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Shuttle Bus
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 
 "The Kids Club at this Paradise Island mega-resort, where even tiny tots can hand-feed baby stingrays and sharks, is way cooler than any parent could ever be." Full review
 "Stays at this modern, family-friendly, beachfront tower include entry to a spectacular 141-acre water park." 
 "Contemporary Caribbean getaway at Atlantis with a water park and private beach." Full review
 Readers' Choice Award
 "A stay at this tower within Atlantis is "like living in your own paradisiacal apartment" with a kitchen, living space, and ocean views." Full review