Graycliff HotelvsCarriearl Boutique Hotel
Both hotels are rated very highly by expert writers. On balance, Graycliff Hotel is preferred by most writers compared to Carriearl Boutique Hotel. Graycliff Hotel ranks #6 in Bahamas with accolades from 3 sources such as Lonely Planet, Gayot and The Telegraph.
Graycliff Hotel
 Frommer's
 Gayot
 The Telegraph
 Lonely Planet
West Hill Street, Nassau 10246, New Providence Island
From $450/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 
 "- Reid Bramblett." Full review
 "A colonial mansion-turned-hotel surrounded by lush tropical gardens." 
9.0
 "Graycliff became an inn in 1844, reverted to a private mansion in the 1940s and, thirty years later, was reborn as an exquisitely-styled boutique hotel. " Full review
Top choice
 "Nassau’s most discreet and character-laden hotel is this slightly spooky 260-year-old home built by a wealthy pirate." Full review
Carriearl Boutique Hotel
 Fodor's
Great Harbour Drive, B56 L13, Great Harbour Cay
From $0/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Restaurant
 - Pool
 
 "Guests staying at this charming boutique hotel talk in superlatives." Full review