Experts' Choice Award Bailey's Ice Cream
What the experts agree on
Bailey's is a beloved island institution famous for its homemade ice cream in two dozen rotating flavors, plus sorbets and frozen yogurt. The turquoise parlor makes a perfect family-friendly stop near Crystal Caves, with affordable treats and a
“This turquoise-hued dessert destination dishes out homemade ice creams, sherbets, sorbets, and frozen yogurts in flavors familiar (Oreo sweet cream, rum raisin) and not”
– Condé Nast Traveler
Fodor's "The popular parlor, directly across from the Swizzle Inn, dishes up some two dozen flavors of homemade all-natural ice creams, plus low-fat frozen yogurts and fat-free sorbets. " Full review
i
This store accepts cash only.
Frommer's "If you’ve got plans to visit the Crystal & Fantasy Caves in Bailey’s Bay, then don’t miss this family-friendly ice cream parlor, which is accessible via a shady tree-lined walkway." Full review
Lonely Planet "Bailey's has long been famous, island-wide, for its locally made ice cream. Choose from a wide array of flavors, which include several sorbets...hot dogs and sandwiches also available." Full review
Fodor's "Choose from over a dozen homemade all-natural ice creams at this iconic parlor easily identified by its bright turquoise exterior. There are plenty of fun flavors for kids, including..." Full review
Afar Magazine
