=

Guana Island

vs

Sugar Mill Hotel

Both properties are rated highly by expert writers. On balance, Sugar Mill Hotel scores significantly better than Guana Island. Sugar Mill Hotel is ranked #2 in British Virgin Islands with praise from 7 reviewers including Jetsetter, oyster.com and Lonely Planet.

Both properties are rated highly by expert writers. On balance, Sugar Mill Hotel scores significantly better than Guana Island. Sugar Mill Hotel is ranked #2 in British Virgin Islands with praise from 7 reviewers including Jetsetter, oyster.com and Lonely Planet.

tripexpert score
75
#16 in British Virgin Islands

From $695/night; best rate guaranteed!

Book Now

location

Guana Island

amenities
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
  • Restaurant
  • Pool
  • Fitness Center
  • Business Center
  • Tennis Court
  • Air Conditioning
  • Beachfront
  • Breakfast included
endorsements
  • 4 endorsements
  • 17

    DK Eyewitness

    A mere 30 guests share 850 acres at this remote retreat off Tortola’s north coast. There are seven lovely beaches scattered around the island.

  • 6

    Fodor's Tick Choice

    Here's a good resort if you want to stroll the hillsides, snorkel around the reefs, swim at its seven beaches, and still enjoy some degree of comfort. Full Review →

  • 4

    Jetsetter

    Privately-owned castaway resort with private terraces, miles of nature trails, and a gourmet restaurant. Full Review →

  • 14

    Concierge

    Guana is the closest you'll get to a private island without a five-figures-a-day tab: Think a maximum of 36 guests spread over seven beaches.

  • Read all reviews →

87
#4 in British Virgin Islands

From $250/night; best rate guaranteed!

Book Now

Apple Bay, Tortola

  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
  • Restaurant
  • Pool
  • Fitness Center
  • Family Friendly
  • Free Parking
  • Multilingual
  • Kitchenette
  • Business Center
  • Air Conditioning
  • Minibar
  • Beach
  • Beachfront
  • Breakfast included
  • 7 endorsements
  • 17

    DK Eyewitness

    With an old sugar mill as its centerpiece, this hotel has 24 rooms, suites, and a villa scattered up the hillside at Apple Bay.

  • 6

    Fodor's Tick Choice

    Though it's not a sprawling resort, the Sugar Mill Hotel has a Caribbean cachet that's hard to beat, and it's a favorite place to stay on Tortola. Full Review →

  • 4

    Jetsetter

    Tortola’s enchanting Sugar Mill Hotel is all about tranquil tropical days, casual candlelit evenings and the island’s finest restaurant just a few paces from your bed Full Review →

  • 1

    Frommer's 33

    This inn combines a first-rate cuisine with intimate accommodations. Full Review →

  • 2

    Lonely Planet

    In a league of its own for ambience, intimacy and customer service, this boutique hotel rises from the ruins of the Appleby Plantation that gave Apple Bay its name. Full Review →

  • Read all reviews →

or use your email address:

Register Login

Already have an account?

Log in →
Forgot password?

Don't have an account yet?

Register →