Map

Nanny Cay Resort Marina vs Sugar Mill Hotel

Both properties are highly recommended by professional reviewers writing for major publications. Overall, Sugar Mill Hotel ranks significantly higher than Nanny Cay Marina & Hotel. Sugar Mill Hotel is ranked #4 in British Virgin Islands with praise from 8 sources like Frommer's, Jetsetter and DK Eyewitness.

Nanny Cay Resort Marina
Nanny Cay Resort Marina
7 / 10
Road Town, Tortola
From $125 /night
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
  • Restaurant
  • Pool
show all amenities
Frommer's Frommer's
"The place is artfully raffish, which seems to be the way its boating clientele here want to keep it." Full review
Fodor's Fodor's
"This quiet oasis is far enough from Road Town to give it a secluded feel but close enough to make shops and restaurants convenient." Full review
DK Eyewitness DK Eyewitness
"Rent power boats, hop into a day sail boat for a trip around Drake’s Passage, or stay ashore to enjoy meals at the two restaurants."
Star Service Star Service
"This hotel, reached via a rutted private road, is often overshadowed by the huge marina that is part of its operation." Full review
Lonely Planet Lonely Planet
"Despite the 'resort' title, Nanny Cay is used more by boaters and business people than pleasure-seeking holidaymakers." Full review
Sugar Mill Hotel
Sugar Mill Hotel
8 / 10
Apple Bay, Tortola
From $250 /night
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Free Breakfast
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
  • Restaurant
show all amenities
Frommer's Frommer's
"This inn combines a first-rate cuisine with intimate accommodations." Full review
Fodor's Fodor's
"Though it's not a sprawling resort, the Sugar Mill Hotel has a Caribbean cachet that's hard to beat, and it's a favorite place to stay on Tortola." Full review
Travel + Leisure Travel + Leisure
"Children under 11 are not permitted from December 12 through April 14, but kids of all ages are welcome the rest of the year. (The hotel is closed August and September.)." Full review
DK Eyewitness DK Eyewitness
"With an old sugar mill as its centerpiece, this hotel has 24 rooms, suites, and a villa scattered up the hillside at Apple Bay."
Star Service Star Service
"The Sugar Mill can't miss when it comes to meeting (and often surpassing) guest expectations. Service is spot-on, and management concerns itself with all of the nuts-and-bolts details." Full review
Show All Reviews