Cape Cadogan Boutique HotelvsThe Bay Hotel
Both hotels are recommended by experts. On balance, Cape Cadogan scores slightly better than The Bay Hotel. Cape Cadogan scores 80 with accolades from 8 publications such as Condé Nast Traveler, Time Out and Concierge.
Cape Cadogan Boutique Hotel Concierge
 Concierge Time Out
 Time Out Frommer's
 Frommer's Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet The Telegraph
 The Telegraph Travel + Leisure
 Travel + Leisure Fodor's
 Fodor's Condé Nast Traveler
 Condé Nast Traveler
5 Upper Union Street, Gardens, Cape Town Central 8000, South Africa
From $226/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Free Breakfast
- Shuttle Bus
- Laundry Service
 "It's a sensual kind of place that feels private, with all-white decor, sparkling chandeliers, and open, travertine-tiled bathrooms." 
 "Comprising the original hotel, nearby luxury apartments and the more private Owners Villa, the Cape Cadogan continues to provide stylish sanctuary for city visitors." Full review
 "One of the original farmhouses built on the slopes of Table Mountain, this elegant double-storied Georgian is just steps away from bustling Kloof Street, yet it's a thoroughly peaceful sanctuary." Full review
 "This Gone with the Wind–style heritage-listed villa presents a very classy boutique operation with some rooms opening on to the secluded courtyard." Full review
8.0
 "An elegant oasis housed in a 19th-century national monument, Cadogan is one of the very best guest houses in the city, with 15 individually decorated rooms." Full review
 "Cape Cadogan is a listed national monument, and its 15 suites reflect this, with ornate fireplaces, plush headboards, and standalone soaking tubs" Full review
 "The staff are pleasant and accommodating and will help you arrange just about anything you need." Full review
 Readers' Choice Award
 "This 15-room Georgian-era townhouse, tucked away in a residential street in Gardens, is full of surprises...such a brilliant location, as slickly managed, luxurious or private as Cape Cadogan." Full review
 i 
Request a room with a separate bathroom if you prefer.
The Bay Hotel Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet DK Eyewitness
 DK Eyewitness Rough Guide
 Rough Guide Time Out
 Time Out Travel + Leisure
 Travel + Leisure Oyster
 Oyster Fodor's
 Fodor's
69 Victoria Road, Camps Bay 8040, South Africa
From $86/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Free Breakfast
- Shuttle Bus
- Laundry Service
 "This old favourite has been a staple of the Camps Bay shoreline for years." Full review
 "This large hotel has a prime position on Camps Bay’s main drag. The grounds are large, with plenty of activities to keep restless guests happy." 
 "Glitzy five-star hotel on the fashionable beachfront strip." 
 "It's impossible not to be seduced by the Copacabana-like views of the beach that's just a hop over the road from this popular hotel." Full review
 "The fun, hip vibe of this beachside hotel is perfectly captured by its open-air cocktail bar—which doubles as a Harley-Davidson rental spot during the summer months." Full review
Upscale
 "Situated across the street from Camps Bay Beach, this four-pearl property offers a wealth of features and chic interiors that attract leisure tourists." Full review
 "The only large hotel in Camps Bay, this luxurious yet relaxed property sits across the street from a white-sand beach and is backed by the towering cliffs of the Twelve Apostles." Full review