Casa Villa ColonialvsMamabella Hostal
Both properties are highly recommended by travel writers. Overall, Hostel Mamallena is preferred by most writers compared to Casa Villa Colonial. Hostel Mamallena comes in at #44 in Cartagena with recommendations from 1 reviews including Lonely Planet.
Casa Villa Colonial
 Michelin Guide
 Lonely Planet
Calle de la Media Luna #10-89, Cartagena, Colombia
From $25/night
- Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 - Kitchenette
 - Air Conditioning
 - Outdoor pool
 
 "This hotel in central Getsemani lies near the old part of Cartagena. A sound mid-range option, Villa Colonial has spotless rooms." 
Top choice
 "Despite steadily rising prices in Getsemaní, rates here remain reasonable and you'll get personal, four-star service, beautiful communal areas with comfortable sofas, and silent air-con for your money" Full review
Mamabella Hostal
 Lonely Planet
Calle Media Luna, Cartagena, Colombia
From $0/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Beach
 - Breakfast included
 - 24-hour front desk
 
 "A sociable, younger crowd gathers at this hostel. It offers plenty of tours – along with a selection of slightly grubby but just-about acceptable rooms." Full review