La SignoriavsColomba Hotel Centre-Ville Historique
Both properties are rated highly by professional reviewers. On balance, La Signoria scores slightly higher than Hotel Colomba. La Signoria scores 76 with recommendations from 2 publications such as Mr & Mrs Smith, Fodor's.
La Signoria
 Fodor's
 Mr & Mrs Smith
Route de la foret de Bonifato, 20260 Calvi, Corsica
From $480/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 
 "From the minute you step onto the honeycombed terra-cotta tiles of this historic 17th-century country manor—a former Genoese estate bestowed by King Louis XV—you'll see why it's part of the luxurious Relaix & Chateaux collection." Full review
 "Ensconce yourself at La Signoria, a romantic hotel blessed with an idyllic setting in a quiet corner of Corsica." Full review
Colomba Hotel Centre-Ville Historique
 Lonely Planet
4-6 rue Simon Varsi, 20169 Bonifacio, Corsica
From $133/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Restaurant
 - Free Parking
 - Air Conditioning
 - Minibar
 - Breakfast in the room
 
 "Occupying a tastefully renovated 14th-century building, this hotel enjoys a prime location on a picturesque (steep) street, bang in the heart of the old town." Full review