Gaia Hotel & Nature ReservevsHacienda AltaGracia, Auberge Resorts Collection
Both properties are endorsed by expert reviewers. On balance, Gaia Hotel & Reserve ranks slightly higher than Hacienda AltaGracia, Auberge Resorts Collection. Gaia Hotel & Reserve comes in at 83 with accolades from 5 publications such as Condé Nast Traveler, Fodor's and Lonely Planet.
Gaia Hotel & Nature Reserve
 Lonely Planet
 Condé Nast Traveler
 Fodor's
 Jetsetter
 Travel + Leisure
 Travel + Leisure
 Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet
 Oyster
Km 2.7 Carretera Quepos a Manuel Antonio, Manuel Antonio National Park 6350, Costa Rica
From $201/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Shuttle Bus
 
 Top Choice
 "This luxurious pile comprises studios, terraces suites and three-story villas and offers nature tours within its expansive grounds – a former wildlife rehabilitation center." Full review
 "Studios, the smallest accommodations, are spare and urbane in style, with views of green hillsides." Full review
 "On 13 acres of private reserve, this boutique hotel is contemporary and very chic, with rooms rendered in slate, hardwood, and rattan with Italian fittings." Full review
 "Sleek Costa Rican retreat with a multilevel infinity pool, swim-up bar and intimate spa with jungle views." Full review
 "The Terra Spa at Gaia is set in the rainforest with views of the Pacific and a menu complete with Reiki energy treatments and Thai and Swedish massages." Full review
 "Won the award for Leading Green Hotel for Central America by the World Travel Awards for its efforts in conservation...operates the preserve while offering suites, studios, and villas." Full review
 Top Choice
 "This luxurious retreat comprises immaculately furnished studios, terrace suites and three-story villas." Full review
Top choice
 "This luxurious retreat comprises immaculately furnished studios, terrace suites and three-story villas" Full review
Luxury
 "This intimate luxury hotel located a 10-minute drive from the entrance to Manuel Antonio National Park is one of the area's top options" Full review
Hacienda AltaGracia, Auberge Resorts Collection
 Afar Magazine
 Condé Nast Traveler
 The Telegraph
 Jetsetter
 Hideaway Report
 Lonely Planet
 Travel + Leisure
Perez Zeledon, San Isidro de El General, Costa Rica
From $340/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
 "The resort is home to 22 stables, the largest riding ring in Central America, and top-notch facilities that include an on-site veterinarian." Full review
 "Tucked high in the mountains of Pérez Zeledon in southern Costa Rica, this 864-acre property—the first Auberge Resort in Central America—brings glamor and luxury to an otherwise rugged terrain." Full review
6.0
 "This five-star new-build luxury estate in the southern foothills of the Cordillera de Talamanca is a serene and polished country retreat." Full review
 "A suite or casita at an idyllic hideaway in an untouched corner of Costa Rica, with a welcome drink." Full review
94.0
 "Luxurious mountainside retreat on 865 acres of gardens and rainforest, three and a half hours southeast of San José." Full review
 Top Choice
 "A hillside hacienda overlooking the lush Valle de General, this Auberge Resort consists of self-contained casitas (cottages) and suites, their decor stylish and understated (neutral shades, dark leather), surrounded by 350 hectares – ideal for hiking, horseback riding and observing from the air from one of the resort's own ultralights" Full review
 "Offers an elevated take on the Costa Rican concept of pura vida, or "pure life"...spread out over 180 lush acres, where guests are encouraged to build their days around interactions with nature"