Baldwin's Guest House CozumelvsCasa Mexicana Cozumel
Both hotels are rated highly by expert writers. On balance, Casa Mexicana Cozumel scores significantly better than Baldwin's Guest House Cozumel. Casa Mexicana Cozumel ranks #1 in Cozumel with accolades from 5 reviewers like Lonely Planet, oyster.com and DK Eyewitness.
Baldwin's Guest House Cozumel
 DK Eyewitness
Ave 55 sur #140, Cozumel 77600
From $0/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Smoking Rooms
 - Pool
 
 "In a quiet part of San Miguel, this little guest house has four ultra-comfortable rooms and a family-sized bungalow with its own kitchen, all within a lush walled garden with a pool." 
Casa Mexicana Cozumel
 Fodor's
 DK Eyewitness
 Frommer's
 Oyster
 Lonely Planet
Av Rafael E Melgar 457 Sur entre 5 y 7, Cozumel 77600
From $89/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 
 "Although not on the beach, this distinctive and inexpensive hotel overlooks the waterfront in San Miguel." Full review
 "Strikingly chic, amply-equipped rooms combine Mexican traditional touches with clean modern lines... making the most of the Caribbean sunlight and superb sunsets." 
 "A favorite with business travelers, the five-story hotel offers excellent free Wi-Fi, irons, desks, and shower-tub combos in the large rooms." Full review
 i 
 Stay away from the rooms on the second floor above the breakfast area, as the noise is considerable all morning
 Mid-Range
 "Casa Mexicana Cozumel is a mid-range hotel with 80 guest rooms located in the heart of San Miguel, just across the street from the ocean and a two-minute walk to Senor Frog's nightclub and restaurant." Full review
 "The breezy open-air lobby with a swimming pool and ocean view is pretty darn sweet here." Full review