Magnolia Hotel Dallas Downtown vs Hotel St. Germain
Magnolia Hotel Dallas Downtown and Hotel St. Germain are both praised by experts. On balance, Magnolia Hotel Dallas Downtown scores significantly higher than Hotel St. Germain. Magnolia Hotel Dallas Downtown ranks #7 in Dallas–Fort Worth with approval from 11 reviews including DK Eyewitness, BlackBook and Fodor's.
Magnolia Hotel Dallas Downtown
Show All Reviews
1401 Commerce St., Dallas, TX 75201
From $110 /night
- Bar/Lounge
- Hot Tub
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Free Breakfast
- Laundry Service
Rough Guide
"This downtown 330-room hotel (housed in the former headquarters of Mobil Oil’s predecessor) is popular with business travellers."
Star Service
"The Magnolia stands in marked contrast to the charming, old-fashioned Adolphus next door; it is cool, modern and offbeat, but with broad appeal."
Full review
i
Service, however, is sluggish at times, and many staff members display indifferent attitudes for even the simplest requests.
Gayot
"A winged Pegasus stands like a beacon atop the historic Magnolia Building, which is located only one block away from shopping paradise."
DK Eyewitness
"Thoroughly modern, this trendy hotel is housed in the historic 1920s Petroleum building downtown."
BlackBook
"Once the tallest building in the Lone Star State, the Magnolia's 29 stories now stand testament to the power of rebranding."
Hotel St. Germain
Show All Reviews
2516 Maple Ave, Dallas, TX 75201
From $0 /night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Concierge
- Restaurant
- Free Parking
Travel + Leisure
"All seven individually designed suites feature a vintage canopy bed, working fireplace, and deep soaking tub."
Full review
Gayot
"This romantic small hotel combines Old World ambience with modern conveniences."
Forbes Travel Guide
Recommended
"Situated in a converted 1906 Victorian mansion in the leafy Uptown neighborhood of Dallas, Texas, is the intimate and romantic Hôtel St. Germain."
Full review
Zagat
"Built as a private mansion, the romantic Hotel St. Germain in Uptown has welcomed guests since 1991 in seven meticulously appointed suites."
Hideaway Report
91.0
"Historic three-story boutique hotel in a converted Victorian mansion with French-inspired décor and traditional service, in fashionable uptown Dallas’ Highland Park."
Full review