Warwick Melrose - DallasvsHotel St. Germain
Both hotels are rated highly by those who travel for a living. Overall, Warwick Melrose - Dallas scores slightly better than Hotel St. Germain. Warwick Melrose - Dallas scores 82 with praise from 10 sources like Zagat, Fodor's and Lonely Planet.
Warwick Melrose - Dallas Frommer's
 Frommer's Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet Oyster
 Oyster Michelin Guide
 Michelin Guide Gayot
 Gayot BlackBook
 BlackBook Zagat
 Zagat Travel + Leisure
 Travel + Leisure Jetsetter
 Jetsetter Fodor's
 Fodor's
3015 Oak Lawn Ave., Dallas, TX 75219
From $92/night
- Pet Friendly
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Laundry Service
- Concierge
 "This is another one of Dallas's upscale hotels with an old-world, rather than an Old West, atmosphere." Full review
 "It's easy to imagine coming to the hotel for a discreet tryst with your beloved." Full review
Upscale
 "This historic property exudes elegance and refinement -- from its stately brick exterior to its ornate lobby with towering columns." Full review
 "Once a luxury apartment block, the historic (1924) Melrose boasts an understated exterior of simple brick with a carved frieze." 
 "Today it sits at one of the best locations in the downtown area, with easy access to Dallas Love Field and the Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport." 
 "Frescoed ceilings, molded columns, curtains made from the finest of fabrics, linens are high on thread counts, marble in the bathrooms." 
4.0
 ""Impeccable" service means a "top-notch" staff "is there for anything you need or want" at this "amazing-looking" "grand old hotel" (built in 1924) boasting "well-appointed" quarters." 
 "Take a step back in time at this historic landmark that immediately makes you feel at home." Full review
 "A comfortable stay at an upscale Dallas hotel within a landmark building – near the buzzing Uptown district." Full review
 "Nestled near an active dining and nightlife neighborhood, this historic building houses a luxury hotel that emphasizes personal service and a residential experience." Full review
Hotel St. Germain Travel + Leisure
 Travel + Leisure Gayot
 Gayot Forbes Travel Guide
 Forbes Travel Guide Zagat
 Zagat Hideaway Report
 Hideaway Report Fodor's
 Fodor's Frommer's
 Frommer's
2516 Maple Ave, Dallas, TX 75201
From $0/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Concierge
- Restaurant
- Free Parking
 "All seven individually designed suites feature a vintage canopy bed, working fireplace, and deep soaking tub." Full review
 "This romantic small hotel combines Old World ambience with modern conveniences." 
 Recommended
 "Situated in a converted 1906 Victorian mansion in the leafy Uptown neighborhood of Dallas, Texas, is the intimate and romantic Hôtel St. Germain." Full review
 "Built as a private mansion, the romantic Hotel St. Germain in Uptown has welcomed guests since 1991 in seven meticulously appointed suites." 
91.0
 "Historic three-story boutique hotel in a converted Victorian mansion with French-inspired décor and traditional service, in fashionable uptown Dallas’ Highland Park." Full review
 "Built as a private residence in 1906, this tiny boutique inn with white-glove service is one of the most romantic in the city." Full review
 "The furniture is of fine antiques, the colors are taken from a painting by Watteau, fireplaces grace many of the suites...grand public spaces on the ground floor turn into a restaurant in the mornings" Full review
 i 
The hotel is set in an old mansion, so there is no elevator