Pension AmaiurvsAtalaya
Both properties are recommended by expert writers. Overall, Pension Amaiur is preferred by most professionals compared to Atalaya. Pension Amaiur has a TripExpert Score of 67 with recommendations from 2 sources such as Rough Guide, Lonely Planet.
Pension Amaiur
 Rough Guide
 Lonely Planet
31 de Agosto, 44, 20003 Donostia-San Sebastian
From $48/night
- Free Internet
 - Kitchenette
 - Flatscreen TV
 
 "Classic old-style budget hotel, in a venerable old house deep in the warren-like streets of the old town. All the rooms differ in size... None is en suite, but each shares a bathroom with one other." 
 Top Choice
 "A top-notch guesthouse in a prime old-town location, Amaiur has bright floral wallpapers and bathrooms tiled in Andalucían blue and white." Full review
Atalaya
 Fodor's
Zabaleta, 38, 20002 Donostia-San Sebastian
From $0/night
 "Tastefully converted from a private house, this 1911 landmark has become a big favorite for quick rail-getaway overnights from Bilbao—the 37-km (22-mile) train ride out is spectacular." Full review