AtalayavsPension Edorta
Atalaya and Pension Edorta are both praised by those who travel for a living. On balance, Pension Edorta scores significantly higher than Atalaya. Pension Edorta comes in at 71 with praise from 2 publications like Rough Guide, Lonely Planet.
Atalaya
 Fodor's
Zabaleta, 38, 20002 Donostia-San Sebastian
From $0/night
 "Tastefully converted from a private house, this 1911 landmark has become a big favorite for quick rail-getaway overnights from Bilbao—the 37-km (22-mile) train ride out is spectacular." Full review
Pension Edorta
 Rough Guide
 Lonely Planet
C/ Puerto , 15 - 1 y 2, 20003 Donostia-San Sebastian
From $55/night
- Free Internet
 - Accessible
 - Fax / photocopying
 - Baggage storage
 - Flatscreen TV
 
 Star
 "In a historic house in the heart of the old town, just up from the harbour. Bright, attractive rooms abound in period charm... Cheapest rates are for those without en-suite facilities." 
 Top Choice
 "A fine pensión with rooms that are all tarted up in brash modern colours, but with a salute to the past in the stone walls and ceilings. It’s very well cared for and well situated." Full review