The Ritz-Carlton, DubaivsOne&Only The Palm
The Ritz-Carlton, Dubai and One&Only The Palm Dubai are both recommended by travel writers. On balance, The Ritz-Carlton, Dubai ranks marginally better than One&Only The Palm Dubai. The Ritz-Carlton, Dubai comes in at 86 with accolades from 11 reviews including Concierge, Travel + Leisure and Frommer's.
The Ritz-Carlton, Dubai
 Frommer's
 Concierge
 Fodor's
 DK Eyewitness
 Rough Guide
 Condé Nast Traveler
 Star Service
 Gayot
 Travel + Leisure
 The Telegraph Show All Reviews 
Jumeirah Beach Residence, JBR, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
From $436/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Shuttle Bus
 
 "Service here is superb - they even have a technology butler who can attend to any of your IT problems." Full review
 "While the Dubai Marina's huge yellow skyscrapers now dwarf this hotel, it still manages to feel like a calm, private retreat." 
 i 
Make sure you don't miss the excellent afternoon tea.
 "This hotel's international reputation for high quality and exquisite service continue at its beachfront property in Dubai." Full review
 "This sumptuous hotel lives up to the reputation of this renowned chain, with lots of marble, chandeliers, Persian carpets and fresh flowers everywhere." 
 "Set in a low-rise, Tuscan-style ochre building this very stylish establishment is one of the classiest and most expensive in the city." 
 "Modeled on a low-rise Mediterranean villa with extensive gardens, this 14-year-old resort in the Dubai Marina also displays Islamic design elements." Full review
 "The first luxury resort on Jumeirah Beach, the Ritz-Carlton now sits amid booming development of the Dubai Marina complex." Full review
 i 
Unfortunately, the renovations have thrown off the staff a bit, causing several to miss or even ignore special requests.
 "Located in the heart of the new Dubai Marina and directly on a white sand beach, The Ritz-Carlton, Dubai is a great way to experience this cosmopolitan city." 
 "A bit of traditional amidst the glitz and glamour of Dubai, the Mediterranean-themed Ritz-Carlton has 138 guest rooms and suites overlooking the Arabian Gulf in the Dubai Marina district." Full review
9.0
 "In a metropolis well versed in excess, Dubai’s Ritz-Carlton delivers luxury with elegant restraint." Full review
One&Only The Palm
 Concierge
 Travel + Leisure
 Star Service
 Lonely Planet
 Afar Magazine
 The Telegraph
 Mr & Mrs Smith
 Hideaway Report
 Oyster
 Condé Nast Traveler Show All Reviews 
West Crescent, Palm Jumeirah, Dubai 114843, United Arab Emirates
From $1,005/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Shuttle Bus
 
 "The nine sea-facing mansions have vast rooms off a central courtyard; rooms in mansion No. 9 offer both beach and city views." 
 "You could be anywhere in the world of luxury island resorts, but in fact this modern Arabian fantasy is located at one end of the crescent that tops the man-made extravaganza of the Palm Jumeirah." Full review
 i 
Book a junior suite in Palm Beach Mansion 6, which has a private pool and beach access.
 "Joining the other deluxe properties on this man-made island, One&Only offers its distinctive luxury at one of the area's smallest hotels." Full review
 i 
Room service, like most any other request, operates on the guest's timetable.
 "The stunning Dubai skyline looms across the Gulf, yet this romantic and megaposh gem offers a complete retreat from the city." Full review
 "One&Only The Palm’s prime position on the tip of the outer breakwater—plus thriving starfish and transplanted mature palm trees—make the beach here feel at once natural and private." Full review
9.0
 "One&Only The Palm is one of Dubai’s most secluded and seductive beachside resorts." Full review
 "The One&Only The Palm resort has extra large rooms, spectacular city views, seaside swimming pools and all the luxuries you need for a top-class UAE vacation." Full review
93.0
 "Glamorous seaside resort on an artificial island, opposite the dramatic Marina district." Full review
 Luxury
 "Situated on the Palm Jumeirah, this luxury resort has a quiet, private feel -- plus an enviable beachfront locale -- which is not an easy feat in the busy city of Dubai." Full review
 Readers' Choice Award
 "This resort compound of modern, sea-facing mansions... private villas, and a restaurant wing... backed by a beautiful pool garden occupies the best position on the man-made Palm Jumeirah island." Full review