Hotel Il TornabuonivsPalazzo Montebello Splendid Firenze
Both properties are praised by professional travelers. On balance, Hotel Tornabuoni Beacci scores slightly higher than Hotel Montebello Splendid. Hotel Tornabuoni Beacci is ranked #22 in Florence with recommendations from 7 reviewers such as The Telegraph, DK Eyewitness and Frommer's.
Hotel Il Tornabuoni
 Frommer's
 Travel + Leisure
 DK Eyewitness
 Star Service
 Rough Guide
 Fodor's
 The Telegraph
 Travel + Leisure
 Travel + Leisure
 The Telegraph
Via Tornabuoni 3, 50123 Florence
From $115/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
 "The staff greets return guests and new friends alike with genuine warmth." Full review
 "Fashion insiders love these 28 characterful rooms... surrounded by haute couture boutiques and across a small piazza from the fresco-filled Santa Trinità church." Full review
 "Once a classic pensione, the hotel has been refitted so guests can now choose between junior suites, deluxe and standard rooms – all with antique furniture and tapestries." 
 "The standard rooms hold ample charm, albeit a bit dated, but the suites are full of formidable antiques, inspired architecture and whimsical decorative elements." Full review
 "This antiques-stuffed four-star hotel offers the best value for money on Florences poshest shopping street." 
 "Florentine pensioni don't get any classier than this: old-fashioned style, enough modern comfort to keep you happy, and a 14th-century palazzo." Full review
8.0
 "This Florentine classic enjoys an excellent location and offers a delightful atmosphere along with modern services and facilities." Full review
 "A 12th-century palazzo, fitting it with 62 boldly colored rooms; think flaming reds, deep indigos, and blazing mustards plus a rooftop terrace." 
Florence Travel Guide
July 7, 2021
 "Art and history also flourish inside this converted 12th-century palazzo...first of Hyatt's Unbound Collection properties in Italy feels glamorously modern, as bold in its patterns and color schemes" 
9.0
 "This smart, stylish hotel enjoys a prime spot on traffic-free Via Tornabuoni and is close to all the main sights and plenty of interesting bars, restaurants and cafés" Full review
Palazzo Montebello Splendid Firenze
 Michelin Guide
 Travel + Leisure
 DK Eyewitness
 Star Service
 Oyster
 Fodor's
Via Garibaldi, 14, 50123 Florence
From $156/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 
 "This stylishly modern hotel is the much frequented haunt of tourists and business people; common areas are spacious and attractively furnished and give onto a delightful internal garden." 
 "Hotel Montebello Splendid, in Santa Maria Novella, delivers elegant interiors... and easy access to the Renaissance city’s best sites—and it’s a great value, to boot." Full review
 "This 19th-century villa with its own giardino all’Italiana (Italian-style garden) was totally refurbished in 2004." 
 "With its spacious public areas, glamorous contempo-traditional design and technology-laden accommodations, it is a standout." Full review
Luxury
 "The 60-room Hotel Montebello Splendid is a luxury boutique hotel situated in a quieter area on the outskirts of central Florence." Full review
 "Once inside the fenced-in confines, guests are treated to a tranquil courtyard which guides them into the marble-laden hotel with a high level of service and a bevy of amenities " Full review