Yoder's Restaurant
What the experts agree on
Yoder's draws crowds for authentic Amish home-cooking and legendary homemade pies—particularly shoofly pie. It's cash-only, alcohol-free, and worth the wait.
“Leave room for Mrs. Yoder's shoofly and other homemade pies, one of the restaurant's biggest draws. Note: Alcohol is neither served nor allowed here.”
– Frommer's
"Lines for meals stretch well beyond the hostess podium here." Full review
i
For breakfast, choose from French toast stuffed with cream cheese or perhaps a hearty stack of pancakes.
"Not just home-cooking, but Amish home-cooking, and what could be homier than that? Finish off with a slice of their famous pie." Full review