Maca BanavsMelodies Guest House
Both properties are praised by writers. Overall, Maca Bana ranks significantly better than Melodies Guest House. Maca Bana comes in at #2 in Grenada with approval from 8 reviews like Lonely Planet, Fodor's and Frommer's.
Maca Bana
 Frommer's
 Fodor's
 Travel + Leisure
 DK Eyewitness
 Star Service
 Oyster
 Jetsetter
 The Telegraph
 Lonely Planet
Magazine Beach, Point Salines, St. George's, Grenada
From $350/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 - Laundy Room
 
 "This is the most charming cottage colony on Grenada." Full review
 "Clustered on a 2-acre hillside overlooking mile-long Magazine Beach, each of Maca Bana's seven private villas (also called "banas") has a great view." Full review
 i 
Sign up for Grenadian cooking lessons with the Aquarium Restaurant chefs. Or perhaps a personal yoga or tai chi lesson on your own deck will do the trick.
 "Set on a verdant bluff above Grenada’s talcum-soft Aquarium Beach on the island’s south shore, this tiny hotel delivers a true sense of place." Full review
 "On the hill above The Aquarium Restaurant sit 5 two- and 2 one-bedroom villas." 
 "Intimate and intricate, this pricey venue trades island style for lots of space on visitors' credit cards." Full review
 i 
This compact, cozy resort is designed to the likes of couples who prefer the intimacy of seeing familiar faces during their vacation while maintaining their privacy in a villa of their own if they so choose.
Upscale
 "This seven-room, upscale boutique resort features one- and two-bedroom self-catering villas in a lush, jungle-like setting." Full review
 "The boutique villa hotel (appropriately named after a tree in the indigenous Arawak language) has an infinity pool and beachside restaurant." Full review
8.0
 "This cluster of individually designed villas sits on a hillside above a picturesque beach, with superlative views out to sea and up the coast." Full review
Top choice
 "Maca Bana has gorgeous villas spreading down a hillside, with fabulous views down the coast to St George’s and every possible detail attended to." Full review
Melodies Guest House
 Lonely Planet
Grenada
From $0/night
 "Melodies has simple rooms, some with balconies facing the impossibly blue ocean." Full review