Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis South/GreenwoodvsIndy Hostel
Both hotels are highly recommended by professional travelers. On balance, Indy Hostel is preferred by most writers compared to Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis South/Greenwood. Indy Hostel comes in at #11 in Indianapolis with positive reviews from 2 publications like Afar Magazine, Rough Guide.
Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis South/Greenwood
 Gayot
5255 Noggle Way, Indianapolis, IN 46237
From $107/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Laundry Service
 - Laundy Room
 
 "Provides access to downtown attractions within a fifteen-minute drive time. ... This 135-room hotel provides a range of guest rooms and suites to choose from, all furnished with thoughtful amenities." 
Indy Hostel
 Rough Guide
 Afar Magazine
 Lonely Planet
4903 Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
From $40/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Free Internet
 - Shuttle Bus
 - Concierge
 - Laundy Room
 - Free Parking
 
 "Appealing small-scale hostel in a former family home, located in a friendly neighbourhood six miles from downtown." 
 "Indy Hostel is right next to the Monon Trail (for biking and walking) and just a short walk to the Upland Brewery tasting room, Recess, Taste Cafe, and Sinking Ship pub." Full review
 "Small, friendly hostel... located by Broad Ripple, so a bit of a haul from downtown (though on bus 17)." Full review