St. Elmo Steak HousevsMilktooth
St. Elmo Steak House and Milktooth are both rated highly by professionals. Overall, St. Elmo Steak House scores slightly higher than Milktooth. St. Elmo Steak House comes in at #1 in Indianapolis with endorsements from 5 reviewers like Fodor's, Zagat and Gayot.
St. Elmo Steak House
Gayot
Fodor's
Zagat
Where
Frommer's
127 S. Illinois, Indianapolis, IN 46225
From $31/night
Gayot14.0
"The atmosphere is a little bit clubby mixed with the aura of an old-time New York steakhouse. The limited dinner menu is short on selections and long on flavor and size." Full review
Fodor's "Expertly done filets, prime rib, ribeye and porterhouse confirm its continuing appeal." Full review
Zagat4.6
"“Steak the way God intended” and a “fiery” shrimp cocktail pack plenty of “zing” at this Downtown landmark delivering “memorable” dinners in a white-tablecloth setting with “top-notch” service." Full review
Where "What started out in 1902 as a small tavern named after the patron saint of sailors has turned into Indianapolis’s oldest steakhouse in its original location." Full review
Frommer's "Popular with celebrities and politicians, this atmospheric National Historic Landmark is the city's premier steakhouse, and has been for over 100 years" Full review
Milktooth Gayot Zagat
Afar Magazine Where Frommer's
Travel + Leisure
534 Virginia Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46203
From $0/night
Gayot13.0
"Milktooth servings are so satisfying, it may be necessary to get a house-made sourdough chocolate croissant or Chinese black rice and plum scone to go." Full review
Zagat "Breakfast and brunch are what's on the menu at this happening Downtown cafe crafting elevated takes on American diner fare using seasonal ingredients...paired with gourmet coffee options." Full review
Afar Magazine "The menu at Milktooth features many childhood breakfast favorites—just maybe not the same childhood that enjoyed Cap'n Crunch and Pop-Tarts." Full review
Where "Indianpolis' first ModBar espresso machine debuts at this breakfast nook where baristas serve up coffee specialties thanks to a multi-roaster program." Full review
Frommer's "Among the top treats here are "dutch baby" pancakes, served in small cast iron frying pans with either a sweet topping (cherries, blackberries, and salted caramel crunch)." Full review
Travel + Leisure "Open four days a week and solely serves brunch. The menu changes frequently, but you can almost always count on a few stellar sweet options as well as savory treats like inventive breakfast sandwiches"
The 15 Best Breakfast Spots in the US
May 19, 2023
