AtholPlace House & VillavsSaxon Hotel, Villas and Spa
Both hotels are endorsed by those who travel for a living. Overall, Saxon Hotel, Villas and Spa scores significantly higher than AtholPlace Hotel & Villa. Saxon Hotel, Villas and Spa scores 91 with recommendations from 10 sources such as Concierge, Condé Nast Traveler and Star Service.
AtholPlace House & Villa
 Concierge
 Condé Nast Traveler
 Afar Magazine
 The Telegraph
 Mr & Mrs Smith
90 Pretoria Ave, Atholl, Sandton 2024, South Africa
From $323/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 
 "When to go: October and November, when the purple-flowering jacaranda trees are in full bloom." 
 "The hotel has a well-stocked library, a lounge cum dining room with an in-house chef, a large pool, and gardens just big enough to stroll in." Full review
 "Despite its central location just a few blocks from the heart of Sandton, AtholPlace retains a secluded air, offering the ultimate urban oasis." Full review
8.0
 "This home-away-from-home, located in a quiet yet accessible part of Johannesburg, comprises a boutique hotel and next-door villa, both furnished in contemporary African décor." Full review
 "If you’re looking for a pre-safari pit stop en route to the awesome Kruger, AtholPlace Hotel & Villa in scenic Sandton has your name on it." Full review
Saxon Hotel, Villas and Spa
 Concierge
 Fodor's
 Star Service
 Travel + Leisure
 Gayot
 Hideaway Report
 The Telegraph
 Lonely Planet
 Afar Magazine
 Condé Nast Traveler
36 Saxon Road | Sandhurst, Sandton 2196, South Africa
From $511/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
 "View the entire 2011 Gold List of the world's best places to stay ›
Also appeared in the Gold List in 2010
Amenities: 
                                
                                 ..." 
 "In the exclusive suburb of Sandhurst, adjacent to the commercial and shopping center of Sandton, the Saxon Hotel has repeatedly received awards for its excellence." Full review
 "On a residential street north of Sandton, this small, luxurious boutique-hotel is the address of choice for moneyed hipsters and power brokers in central Sandhurst." Full review
 i 
There are six swimming pools from which guests can choose.
 World's Best Hotels
 "Latticed shutters, 10 acres of landscaped gardens, and an air of tranquility create a sense of seclusion at this all-suite boutique retreat, set in a quiet, tree-lined Johannesburg suburb." Full review
 "Elegance and hospitality minutes away from the shopping and business centers of Johannesburg." 
96.0
 "Formerly a private mansion, this was where Nelson Mandela wrote his autobiography. Now a gracious boutique property centered on a stunning lobby framed by two sweeping staircases." Full review
8.0
 "A historic Johannesburg hotel, set in a 10-acre oasis of manicured gardens, attracting a well-heeled mix of guests and locals." Full review
 "The pride of Sandhurst is a palatial suite hotel where Mandela completed his famed memoir." Full review
 " The Saxon gently lulls guests into safari mode, cosseting them in its decadent comforts and enveloping them with its sophisticated African-chic decor and earthy tones." Full review
 Readers' Choice Award
 ""Everything is over the top" at the former private home of an insurance magnate, where Nelson Mandela worked on his book Long Walk to Freedom." Full review