Seashell Motel & Key West Hostel vs ?

"This isn’t our favorite hostel, but it’s about the only youth-oriented budget choice on the island." Full review

"A mere three-minute walk to the beach and to Old Key West, this hostel is usually full of young backpackers."

"The cheapest digs in town are these grubby dorms, run by a friendly owner who provides bikes for rent."

"Cheap dorm rooms down near the Southernmost Point, a five-minute walk from central Old Town." Full review

"This well-run hostel is a 3-minute walk to the beach and Old Town. Very busy with European backpackers, it's a great place to meet people." Full review