Sumiya RyokanvsMatsubaya Ryokan
Both hotels are endorsed by experts. Overall, Matsubaya Inn is preferred by most professionals compared to Sumiya Ryokan. Matsubaya Inn is ranked #22 in Kyoto with approval from 4 publications including Lonely Planet, Insight Guides and Fodor's.
Sumiya Ryokan
 Frommer's
433 Shirakabecho, Nakagyo-ku, Fuyacho Sanjo-kudaru, Kyoto, Kyoto Prefecture 604-8075
From $0/night
- Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Air Conditioning
 - Refrigerator
 
 "Like the other traditional Japanese inns listed here, the 100-year-old Sumiya has a great location in a typical Kyoto neighborhood just a few minutes' walk from bustling downtown." Full review
 i 
The oldest rooms employ a striking variety of different woods in their design (be sure to notice the Edo-Era designs on the sliding doors), while rooms in a 45-year-old addition may have sliding screen doors that open onto a private garden.
Matsubaya Ryokan
 Insight Guides
 Fodor's
 Frommer's
 Lonely Planet
Higashinotoin Nishi-iru, Kamijuzuyacho-dori, Shimogyo-ku, Kyoto, Kyoto Prefecture 600-8150
From $44/night
- Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Laundy Room
 - Multilingual
 - Air Conditioning
 - Fax / photocopying
 
 "Cosy but highly efficiently run ryokan dating back to the Meiji era. All rooms are Japanese style and the bathing communal." 
 "You won't find kimono-clad attendants here, but you also won't find wallet-emptying rates." Full review
 "Rooms are mostly Japanese style, with the best overlooking the garden. Also good bets are five Western-style rooms on the fifth floor with kitchenettes and tiny balconies." Full review
 Top Choice
 "A short walk from Kyoto Station, this newly renovated ryokan has clean, well-kept rooms and a management that is used to foreign guests." Full review