La TorrevsStella
Both properties are endorsed by professional travelers. Overall, La Torre is the choice of most reviewers compared to Affittacamere Stella. La Torre ranks #23 in Lucca with approval from 2 reviews like Rough Guide, Lonely Planet.
La Torre
 Lonely Planet
 Rough Guide
Piazza del Carmine, 11, 55100 Lucca
From $55/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Free Internet
 - Kitchenette
 - Flatscreen TV
 - Refrigerator
 
 "Overlooks a red-brick tower on Piazza del Carmine. Our independent authors have visited La Torre 1 and selected this as one of our recommended guesthouses in Lucca." Full review
 "Five
appealing double rooms, not all en-suite, just off
Piazza del Carmine in a quiet part of the walled town.
The same owners run two other outlets, Torre 2 and
Torre 3, at Via della..." 
Stella
 Lonely Planet
Via Pisana Traversa 2, no74, S Anna, 55100 Lucca
From $52/night
- Free Internet
 - Free Parking
 - Air Conditioning
 - Fax / photocopying
 - Baggage storage
 - Flatscreen TV
 
 "Just outside the Porta Sant’Anna, this well-regarded guesthouse in an early 20th-century apartment building offers comfortable and attractive rooms... a kitchen for guests’ use and private parking." Full review