Mauricia Beachcomber Resort & SpavsOne&Only Le Saint Geran
Both properties are rated highly by expert writers. On balance, One&Only Le Saint Geran ranks significantly better than Mauricia Beachcomber Resort & Spa. One&Only Le Saint Geran comes in at 87 with recommendations from 5 reviews including The Telegraph, Condé Nast Traveler and Travel + Leisure.
Mauricia Beachcomber Resort & Spa
 Lonely Planet
 Oyster
Royal Road, Grand Baie, Mauritius
From $144/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Shuttle Bus
 - Laundry Service
 
 "With Titanic proportions (the hotel's design was inspired by the shape of an oceanliner), this option boasts an endless array of activities from watersports to the on-site nightclub." 
Upper-middle-range
 "The 237-room Mauricia Beachcomber Resort & Spa is a busy upper-middle-range property in the heart of Grand Baie." Full review
One&Only Le Saint Geran
 Fodor's
 Travel + Leisure
 The Telegraph
 Condé Nast Traveler
Pointe de Flacq, Poste De Flacq, Mauritius 230
From $1,064/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 
 "Suites have a private terrace or balcony facing either the ocean or the bay... Michelin-star chef Vineet Bhatia looks after the resort's Rasoi by Vineet restaurant." Full review
 "One & Only offers cookouts by the tent—marshmallows included—served by a liveried butler." Full review
9.0
 "The Grand Dame of Mauritius hotels is a style icon, set on a private peninsula, and service is legendary." Full review
 Readers' Choice Award
 "You are, by default, a naturalist and birdwatcher here, since you’re off the southeast coast of Madagascar on sublimely tropical Mauritius." Full review