Both hotels are rated highly by writers. Overall, Shirah's Guest House ranks slightly higher than Bayview Hotel Melaka. Shirah's Guest House scores 72 with praise from 2 reviews like Lonely Planet, Rough Guide.
Shirah's Guest House
No. 207B, 208, 209B, 2nd Floor, Taman Melaka Raya, Bandar Hilir, Melaka 75000, Malaysia
From $0 /night
"Brightly painted walls and a gentle Malay welcome make this place sit somewhere between a backpackers and a homestay. Some rooms have balconies and all have high ceilings." Full review
"With only six rooms and a small roof terrace, this place is well looked after and has brightly coloured murals on the walls. Two a/c rooms share a lovely balcony and all have shared showers."