Batman's Hill On CollinsvsAtlantis Hotel
Both properties are rated very highly by those who travel for a living. On balance, Quality Hotel Batman's Hill on Collins scores marginally better than Atlantis Hotel. Quality Hotel Batman's Hill on Collins has a TripExpert Score of 75 with endorsements from 3 sources including Oyster, Rough Guide and Lonely Planet.
Batman's Hill On Collins Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet Rough Guide
 Rough Guide Oyster
 Oyster
623 Collins Street & Spencer Street, Melbourne, Victoria 3000
From $94/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Laundry Service
- Concierge
- Laundy Room
 "Ideal for travellers looking for central, comfortable and reasonably priced digs." Full review
 i 
Opt for a Club room for space to strew the luggage and upgraded bathrooms.
 "An elegant Edwardian exterior belies a functional and modern interior. The wide range of facilities includes bars, a restaurant and 24hr room service. $150." 
Mid-Range
 "This three-pearl, 190-room historic hotel has a prime location in the center of Melbourne." Full review
Atlantis Hotel DK Eyewitness
 DK Eyewitness Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet
300 Spencer Street, Melbourne, Victoria 3000
From $50/night
- Free Internet
- Laundry Service
- Concierge
- Laundy Room
- Pool
- Fitness Center
 "Opened in 2002, this hotel is well positioned for visitors arriving via train or bus at Southern Cross Station." 
 "Handy for Southern Cross and Flagstaff stations but in a drab, traffic-clogged part of town, this dependable hotel offers comfortable modern rooms that are soothingly neutral if not super stylish." Full review