Brotherhood of Thieves

"“Everyone seems to know and like” this “historical” “hole-in-the-wall” on Nantucket, since they leave “full and happy” from the moderately priced, “comforting” American “bar food kicked up a notch”; indeed, it's a “local hangout”, with a “quaint, dark and cozy” basement tavern, an upstairs dining room and an “amazing” beer garden out back" Full review

"No, it's not really an 1840s whaling bar—though the atmospheric basement, which dates all the way back to 1972, presents a more convincing front than the newer, spiffier upper floors, which attract families and friendly singles alike" Full review