Calistoga Inn Restaurant & BreweryvsInn St Helena
Both properties are praised by travel writers. On balance, Calistoga Inn is the choice of most professionals compared to Inn St Helena. Calistoga Inn ranks #20 in Napa Valley with accolades from 4 reviewers including Rough Guide, Lonely Planet and Gayot.
Calistoga Inn Restaurant & Brewery
 Rough Guide
 Fodor's
 Gayot
 Lonely Planet
1250 Lincoln Ave, Calistoga, CA 94515
From $0/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Breakfast
 - Restaurant
 - Free Parking
 - Breakfast included
 - Highchairs available
 
 Star
 "Relaxing, excellent-value rooms, most with private bath, in a landmark building with its own restaurant and microbrewery right on the main street, creating a lively atmosphere." 
 "Calistoga's comeback kid emerged from the ashes of a 2012 fire with a fresh look and a new menu, and the beers made on-site are better than ever." Full review
 "Comfy Napa Valley lodging above a lively microbrewery." 
 Top Choice
 "Upstairs from a busy bar, this inn has 18 clean, basic rooms with shared bath, ideal for no-fuss bargain-hunters. No TVs, no elevator. Bring earplugs." Full review
Inn St Helena
 Rough Guide
1515 Main St, St. Helena, CA 94574
From $179/night
- Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Free Parking
 - Air Conditioning
 - Breakfast included
 
 "Luxury accommodation in the 1872 house once inhabited by Bierce himself (see St Helena). Breakfast is washed down with complimentary Champagne."