Napa River Inn at the Historic Napa MillvsPoetry Inn Napa Valley
Both Napa River Inn at the Historic Napa Mill and Poetry Inn are endorsed by those who travel for a living. Overall, Napa River Inn at the Historic Napa Mill is the choice of most professionals compared to Poetry Inn. Napa River Inn at the Historic Napa Mill scores 84 with recommendations from 8 reviews including Gayot, Michelin Guide and Forbes Travel Guide.
Napa River Inn at the Historic Napa Mill
 Michelin Guide
 Fodor's
 Gayot
 Forbes Travel Guide
 Jetsetter
 The Telegraph
 Frommer's
 U.S. News & World Report
 Lonely Planet
500 Main Street, Napa, CA 94559
From $229/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 
 "Set within a two-acre riverfront complex bursting with bars and restaurants, there's simply nothing else like it around...The Inn is the crown jewel of this downtown Napa landmark." 
 "Part of a complex of restaurants, shops, a nightclub, and a spa, this waterfront inn is within easy walking distance of downtown hot spots." Full review
 "Reinventing casual luxury on the grounds of an old mill." 
 Recommended
 "It may have only 66 guest rooms, but the boutique Napa River Inn has left an outsized footprint on the heart of downtown Napa, both literally and figuratively." Full review
 "Historic downtown Napa landmark with wine-tastings, riverside dining and an onsite bakery." Full review
8.0
 "Napa River Inn is an easy walk from everything you’d want to do during a stay in downtown Napa, set on two riverfront acres." Full review
 "This boutique hotel in a historic building and two annexes hits a homerun by paying attention to the details...you get local bath products, breakfast delivered to your room, in-room coffee." Full review
 i 
Bonus: It’s on the same block as impossible-to-resist Sweetie Pies bakery and Angèle ★★ restaurant.
17.0
 "This hotel has all the resources available to provide guests with the quintessential Napa Valley wine vacation" Full review
 "The inn has upper-midrange rooms, Victoriana to modern, in three satellite buildings. Walkable to restaurants and bars." Full review
Poetry Inn Napa Valley
 Fodor's
 Travel + Leisure
 Gayot
 Lonely Planet
 Afar Magazine
 goop
 Hideaway Report
 Lonely Planet
6380 Silverado Trail, Napa, CA 94558
From $889/night
- Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Concierge
 - Pool
 
 "Indoors, the polished service, comfortably chic decor, and amenities that include a private spa and a fully stocked wine cellar only add to the exquisite pleasure of a stay here." Full review
 "With just three rooms, the Poetry Inn is one of the most tranquil spaces in the buzzing Napa Valley." Full review
 "A sophisticated inn on the grounds of a Napa vineyard." 
 "There’s no better valley view than from this contemporary three-room inn, high on the hills east of Yountville." Full review
 "The only hotel in the coveted Stags Leap district of Napa Valley, the inn has the kind of customized, one-step-ahead-of-you service normally reserved for landed gentry." Full review
 "Although the rooms feel accordingly secluded and private, almost all of them have excellent views of the nearby hills. The décor is understated but elegant." Full review
95.0
 "This dramatic sanctuary in the Stags Leap District is perched on a hilltop providing spectacular views of the pastoral valley below." Full review
 "There’s no better valley view than from this contemporary five-room inn, high on the hills east of Yountville. Decorated with posh restraint, rooms have private balcony, wood-burning fireplace" Full review