Map

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel vs The Roger New York

Both properties are rated highly by professionals. On balance, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel ranks significantly better than The Roger. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel ranks #15 in New York City with positive reviews from 19 sources including DK Eyewitness, Time Out and Insight Guides.

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
9 / 10
35 East 76th Street, New York City, NY 10021
From $383 /night
  • Pet Friendly
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
show all amenities
Michelin Guide
"Perfectly sited on Madison Avenue and surrounded by leading boutiques and galleries, this hotel is equal parts exclusive hideaway and world-class hotel."
Frommer's
"This 34-story grande dame towers over Madison Avenue, perfectly epitomizing the old-world, moneyed neighborhood where it stands." Full review
Concierge
"The most pedigreed of the Upper East Side hotels, this grande dame opened originally as a residential hotel in 1930, with composer Richard Rodgers as its first occupant."
Fodor's
"The Carlyle's fusion of venerable elegance and Manhattan swank calls for the aplomb of entering a Chanel boutique: walk in chin-high, wallet out, and ready to be impressed." Full review
Insight Guides
"The great bastion of Old New York caters to royals, politicians, and other elites, housing them in refined Art Deco-inspired guestrooms and pampering them with attentive service."
Show All Reviews
The Roger New York
8 / 10
131 Madison Avenue, New York City, NY 10016
From $195 /night
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
  • Restaurant
show all amenities
Rough Guide
Star
"The first thing you’ll notice at Roger Williams is the use of colour; the Scandinavian/Japanese fusion rooms utilize both mellow and vibrant tones"
Frommer's
"One of the top choices in what is a quiet yet convenient Midtown location." Full review
Fodor's
"A colorful choice in a rather plain neighborhood, the Roger continues to have a following among repeat visitors to New York, especially since its 2012 redesign." Full review
Jetsetter
"Dapper New York dandy with classic cocktails and New American fare on Madison Avenue." Full review
DK Eyewitness
"A stylish option for those with a little more to spend, and the amenities make it worth the price – free breakfast, all-day serve-yourself coffee and treats, and a DVD library."
Show All Reviews

© Tripexpert Inc.