The Wagner at the Battery vs ?

"This luxurious modern hotel has all the bells and whistles ... sleek interior design, top-notch services, and oh, those views!"

"If you don't mind the location and the commute to Midtown and beyond, you won't find a more luxurious choice." Full review

"If you're staying this far downtown, the Ritz is your top choice." Full review

"Telescopes in the elegantly modern rooms offer spectacular close-up views of the Statue of Liberty and New York Harbor."

"The Ritz-Carlton's downtown property offers everything you'd expect from a deluxe Manhattan hotel: dramatic vistas... luxurious bedding and an indulgent spa." Full review