=

Gotham Bar & Grill

vs

Eleven Madison Park

Both restaurants are endorsed by professional reviewers writing for major publications. On balance, Eleven Madison Park is the choice of most professionals compared to Gotham Bar & Grill. Eleven Madison Park has a TripExpert Score of 97 with recommendations from 17 publications like The Infatuation, Fodor's and Forbes Travel Guide.

Both restaurants are endorsed by professional reviewers writing for major publications. On balance, Eleven Madison Park is the choice of most professionals compared to Gotham Bar & Grill. Eleven Madison Park has a TripExpert Score of 97 with recommendations from 17 publications like The Infatuation, Fodor's and Forbes Travel Guide.

tripexpert score
88
#63 in New York City
location

12 E 12th St, Frnt 1, New York, NY 10003

endorsements
  • 19 endorsements
  • 22

    BlackBook

    Alfred, bring me my bat-fork! Chef Alfred Portale's destination is a reliable draw even over a quarter-century later.

  • 8

    Condé Nast Traveler

    Service here is as precise as a German automobile, but never fussy or formal. Full Review →

  • 17

    DK Eyewitness

    A New York classic of modern American cuisine showcasing revolutionary chef Alfred Portale’s creations such as gingerbread crusted foie gras.

  • 6

    Fodor's Tick Choice

    People come for Portale's transcendent preparations: no rack of lamb is more tender, no seafood salad sweeter. Full Review →

  • 53

    Forbes Travel Guide 92

    Acclaimed chef Alfred Portale is a perfectionist who pioneered architecturally inspired food presentation. Full Review →

  • Read all reviews →

97
#1 in New York City

11 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10010

  • 21 endorsements
  • 22

    BlackBook

    Food king Danny Meyer brought in young alchemist chef Daniel Humm and kick started this tired power luncher overnight.

  • 8

    Condé Nast Traveler Tick Editor's Pick

    Though many of his dishes are intricate and presented with pomp, Humm is inspired by simplicity and fresh ingredients. The five-hour, 15-course tasting menu is also a point of pride for gourmands. Full Review →

  • 17

    DK Eyewitness

    The Art Deco dining room with soaring ceilings and views of historic Madison Square Park make this the most elegant of Danny Meyer’s restaurant empire.

  • 6

    Fodor's Tick Choice

    Luxury, precision, and creativity are the driving forces at this internationally renowned restaurant. Full Review →

  • 53

    Forbes Travel Guide 91

    The large scale of the Art Deco dining room of Eleven Madison Park... contrasts with the modestly-sized food portions. Full Review →

  • Read all reviews →
Book Now on Booking.com
BEST RATE GUARANTEED

or use your email address:

Register Login

Already have an account?

Log in →
Forgot password?

Don't have an account yet?

Register →