Old Stone Inn Boutique HotelvsThe Giacomo Hotel
Both properties are rated highly by those who travel for a living. On balance, Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel ranks significantly better than The Giacomo. Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel scores 77 with positive reviews from 2 reviewers like Lonely Planet, oyster.com.
Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel
 Lonely Planet
 Oyster
 Travel + Leisure
5425 Robinson Street, Niagara Falls, Ontario L2G 7L6, Canada
From $142/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Restaurant
 
 "One of few independents in the area, the Old Stone Inn sits on a rather forlorn block, but is still just minutes from the Falls." 
Mid-Range
 "The three-pearl, 110-room hotel Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel has a lot of character even if it doesn't exactly fit "boutique hotel" criteria." Full review
 "Afterward, we retired to the historic Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel (doubles from $159), located steps from the water" 
The Giacomo Hotel
 Insight Guides
 Lonely Planet
222 First Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14303
From $84/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
 "Opened in 2010, the Giacomo stepped into a 1929 Art Deco former post office. It has more charm than the usual chains in town and is just a few minutes’ walk from the falls." 
 Top Choice
 "A rare bit of style on either the US or Canadian sides, the luxe Giacomo occupies part of a gorgeous art-deco office tower, with spacious, ornately decorated rooms." Full review