Hotel ElchvsFive Reasons Hotel & Hostel
Both properties are endorsed by professionals. On balance, Hotel Elch scores significantly higher than Five Reasons Hotel & Hostel. Hotel Elch comes in at 88 with positive reviews from 3 reviewers including Frommer's, Rough Guide and Lonely Planet.
Hotel Elch
 Lonely Planet
 Rough Guide
 Frommer's
Irrerstrasse 9, 90403 Nuremberg, Bavaria
From $77/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Laundry Service
 - Restaurant
 - Multilingual
 
 "Tucked up in the antiques quarter, this 14th-century, half-timbered house has morphed into the snuggest, most romantic 12-room gem of a hotel you could imagine." Full review
 Star
 "Superbly located and really friendly, good-value option in a fourteenth-century half-timbered house in the northern Altstadt. Modern comforts include shower and WC... Pets and families are welcome." 
 "A 14th-century half-timbered house just below the castle is the atmospheric setting for some of Nurnberg’s most character-filled and good-value accommodations" Full review
Five Reasons Hotel & Hostel
 Lonely Planet
Frauentormauer 42, 90402 Nuremberg, Bavaria 
From $23/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Multilingual
 - Baggage storage
 - 24-hour front desk
 
 "90-bed hostel with spotless dorms, the trendiest hostel bathrooms you are ever likely to encounter, pre-made beds, card keys, fully equipped kitchen, a small bar and very nice staff." Full review