Comfort Suites Maingate EastvsLoews Portofino Bay Hotel
Both properties are highly recommended by professional reviewers. On balance, Loews Portofino Bay Hotel at Universal Orlando scores significantly higher than Comfort Suites Maingate East. Loews Portofino Bay Hotel at Universal Orlando comes in at #3 in Orlando with endorsements from 12 publications like Rough Guide, Insight Guides and The Telegraph.
Comfort Suites Maingate East
 Rough Guide
 Oyster
 Frommer's
2775 Florida Plaza Blvd, Kissimmee, FL 34746
From $84/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Shuttle Bus
 
 Star
 "This chain motel offers good value for money, comfortable, clean suites and a free deluxe continental breakfast, just a few miles from Disney’s main gate. $99." 
Mid-Range
 "Comfort Suites Maingate East is a 198-room mid-range hotel that's located within driving distance to the Orlando area theme parks." Full review
 "Set back from the main drag, this welcoming hotel is one of the nicest in the area." Full review
Loews Portofino Bay Hotel
 Concierge
 Insight Guides
 Fodor's
 DK Eyewitness
 Rough Guide
 Michelin Guide
 Star Service
 Gayot
 Zagat
 The Telegraph Show All Reviews 
5601 Universal Blvd., Orlando, FL 32819
From $266/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Shuttle Bus
 
 "Universal boasts the property is its most sumptuous, and while it's truly comfortable, it's still at heart a very busy property catering to theme park vacationers." 
 "With a huge lagoon-style pool, a small sand beach, and Saturday "luaus" (Hawaian feasts), this Pacific Rim-themed hotel is particularly relaxing." 
 "The charm and romance of Portofino, Italy—destination of Europe's rich and famous—are conjured up at this lovely luxury resort." Full review
 "The charm and ambience of the Italian seaside village of Portofino have been meticulously re-created at this lavish resort." 
 "A lavishre-creation of the Italian seaside village of Portofino, complete with vintage scooters parked in the piazza." 
 "Operated by the Loews Corp on Universal theme-park property, this colorful hotel edges a large body of water like the bayside Italian fishing village for which it is named." 
 "Located inside Universal Studios, this polished top-shelf theme resort offers direct access via walkway to the park's CityWalk shops and restaurants." Full review
 "This is Portofino, although it is far removed from the location where you would probably expect to find it---the lovely lower thigh of the Italian boot." 
4.0
 "Pretend like you're "visiting Italy" at this "upscale" Portofino-inspired resort that's "in the midst of amusement park excitement" while still providing a "relaxing" oasis." 
9.0
 "The array of amenities is impressive and the dining is superb." Full review