Oaks Queenstown Shores ResortvsPencarrow
Both properties are rated highly by travel writers. Overall, Pencarrow ranks marginally better than Oaks Shores. Pencarrow comes in at #22 in Queenstown with approval from 2 sources including Fodor's, Frommer's.
Oaks Queenstown Shores Resort
 Oyster
327 - 343 Frankton Road, Queenstown 9197, New Zealand
From $88/night
- Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Laundry Service
 - Laundy Room
 - Restaurant
 - Fitness Center
 
Upscale
 "The upscale Oaks Shores is a (mostly) apartment-style hotel on the shores of picturesque Lake Wakatipu, about a four-minute drive from Queenstown's center (the hotel offers free shuttle service)." Full review
Pencarrow
 Fodor's
 Frommer's
678 Frankton Road, Queenstown, New Zealand
From $91/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Free Parking
 - Spa
 
 "It's not just the hillside backdrop by Lake Wakatipu, or the gardens, or the spacious guest rooms that set this place apart; it's the the friendliness and service of the hosts." 
 "Factor in four fabulous big rooms...not to mention great views and an unforgettable breakfast -- and you’ll see why I rate this as one of the best B&B stays in the country." Full review