The Kenwood InnvsHampton Inn & Suites St. Augustine-Vilano Beach
Both properties are endorsed by professional reviewers. On balance, The Kenwood Inn is the choice of most reviewers compared to Hampton Inn & Suites St. Augustine - Vilano Beach. The Kenwood Inn comes in at 78 with endorsements from 3 publications such as Frommer's, Rough Guide and oyster.com.
The Kenwood Inn
 Rough Guide
 Oyster
 Frommer's
38 Marine St., Saint Augustine, FL 32084
From $204/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Pool
 - Free Parking
 - Meeting Rooms
 
 "Enjoying a peaceful location, this 1880s Queen Anne Victorian gem features gorgeous period rooms, its own pool, and a complimentary cocktail hour every day. Free use of bikes for guests." 
 Upscale
 "A Victorian-era, Queen Anne-style bed and breakfast on the edge of the old city, the three-story upscale Kenwood Inn offers 13 individually decorated rooms." Full review
 "This three-story, 13-room Queen Victorian stunner is the oldest continuously operating inn in St. Augustine. Common areas are inviting and cozy...and there are a few dog-friendly rooms." Full review
Hampton Inn & Suites St. Augustine-Vilano Beach
 Oyster
95 Vilano Rd, Vilano Beach, FL 32084
From $111/night
- Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Laundy Room
 - Pool
 
Budget
 "Rooms and suites are spacious, with kitchenettes and flat-screen TVs, and some have balconies with great ocean views." Full review