The Pirate Haus InnvsThe Collector Luxury Inn & Gardens
Both The Pirate Haus Inn and The Collector - Luxury Inn & Gardens are endorsed by professional reviewers. Overall, The Pirate Haus Inn ranks marginally better than The Collector - Luxury Inn & Gardens. The Pirate Haus Inn comes in at 74 with approval from 2 sources including DK Eyewitness, Rough Guide.
The Pirate Haus Inn
 DK Eyewitness
 Rough Guide
 Lonely Planet
32 Treasury Street, Saint Augustine, FL 32084
From $86/night
- Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Family Friendly
 - Free Parking
 - Business Center
 
 "International travelers on a budget love this place located smack in the middle of the historic district. A communal kitchen, living room, and rooftop terrace make it easy to socialize." 
 Star
 "A renovated pirate-themed hotel/ hostel with a giant kitchen and a common room stuffed with local guidebooks. All of the five private rooms have a/c, and you can make your own pancake breakfast." 
 "A-har me hearties! Although far from St Augustine's fanciest digs, this family-friendly European-style guesthouse/hostel may well be the cheapest and most cheerful" Full review
The Collector Luxury Inn & Gardens
 The Telegraph
 Travel + Leisure
149 Cordova Street, Saint Augustine, FL 32084
From $0/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
9.0
 "The Collector is a unique set of historic buildings in arguably America’s most history-laden city, with all the charm of a country b&b and the panache of a boutique hotel." Full review
 "Located on famous Cordova Street but a few minutes by foot from all the hubbub, The Collector Inn is a stunning retreat with elements of history, intrigue, whimsy, and romance"