Ye Olde Nags HeadvsYHA Edale
Both properties are praised by professional reviewers. On balance, Ye Olde Nags Head scores marginally better than YHA Edale. Ye Olde Nags Head comes in at #12 in Sheffield with accolades from 1 publications including Lonely Planet.
Ye Olde Nags Head
 Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet
Cross Street, Castleton S33 8WH
From $0/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Restaurant
 - Free Parking
 
 "The cosiest of the 'residential' pubs along the main road, offering 10 comfortable, well-appointed rooms (some with four-poster beds and spas)." Full review
 "The cosiest of the 'residential' pubs along the main road has nine comfortable, well-appointed rooms; top-category rooms have four-poster beds and spas" Full review
YHA Edale
 Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet
Rowland Cote, Nether Booth, Edale S33 7ZH
From $0/night
- Family Friendly
 - Free Parking
 
 "Spectacular views across to Back Tor unfold from this country-house hostel 1.5 miles east of Edale." Full review
 "Spectacular views across to Back Tor unfold from this country-house hostel...all 157 beds are bunks; wi-fi in public areas only." Full review