The White Star TavernvsThe Old Vine
Both hotels are rated highly by writers. Overall, The White Star Tavern ranks significantly higher than The Old Vine. The White Star Tavern ranks #3 in Southampton with approval from 2 reviews such as The Telegraph, Rough Guide.
The White Star Tavern
 Rough Guide
 The Telegraph
28 Oxford Street, Southampton SO14 3DJ
From $62/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Restaurant
 - Meeting Rooms
 - Minibar
 
 "Boutique-style rooms with comfortable beds, trendy toiletries, free wi-fi and modern decor, in this lively hotel above a highly regarded barrestaurant. £95." 
9.0
 "A characterful tavern with rooms on Southampton’s vibrant Oxford Street." Full review
The Old Vine
 Fodor's
8 Great Minster Street, Winchester SO23 9HA
From $127/night
- Free Internet
 - Restaurant
 - Free Parking
 - Multilingual
 - Air Conditioning
 - Breakfast in the room
 
 "Blessed with an ideal location opposite the cathedral, this 18th-century inn, now a gastro-pub with rooms, has received a smart, modern makeover without losing any of its character." Full review