Hotel Villa Lodge 4 EpicesvsHotel Manapany
Both hotels are rated very highly by travel writers. Overall, Hotel Manapany Cottages & Spa scores significantly better than Hotel Villa Lodge 4 Epices. Hotel Manapany Cottages & Spa scores 79 with praise from 4 reviewers including Star Service, Frommer's and BlackBook.
Hotel Villa Lodge 4 Epices
 BlackBook
97133, St. Barthelemy
From $481/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
 "Just a few yards above the beach, the complex is built on top one of the oldest stone cisterns on the island and is terraced into a hill that overlooks the lagoon in Grand Cul de Sac." 
Hotel Manapany
 Frommer's
 Star Service
 BlackBook
 The Telegraph
Anse des Cayes 97098, St Barthelemy
From $612/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 
 "This stylish resort climbs a steep, landscaped hillside on the northwest side of the island, a 10-minute taxi ride north of the airport." Full review
 "Off a bumpy, circuitous road, three kilometers across the island from Gustavia's pretty port, this north-shore cottage complex relies more on savoir faire and ambience than on extensive facilities." Full review
 i 
Try to avoid Standard rooms in the lowest two rows, as they lie close to the parking lot.
 "Return to nature among acres of unruly palms. Deluxe, not rustic,  red-roofed cottages scatter the hillside like a fairy tale village." 
 i 
Bring a lover and ask for a room with the wooden four posters.
7.0
 "Eco-sensitive with a free and easy style, the colourful five-star Manapany is a holiday resort tuned to our times" Full review