Hotel Villa Lodge 4 EpicesvsLe P'tit Morne Hotel
Both hotels are highly recommended by professional reviewers. On balance, Le P'tit Morne Hotel ranks significantly higher than Hotel Villa Lodge 4 Epices. Le P'tit Morne Hotel comes in at #18 in St. Barth's with recommendations from 4 sources including Fodor's, Frommer's and BlackBook.
Hotel Villa Lodge 4 Epices
 BlackBook
97133, St. Barthelemy
From $481/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
 "Just a few yards above the beach, the complex is built on top one of the oldest stone cisterns on the island and is terraced into a hill that overlooks the lagoon in Grand Cul de Sac." 
Le P'tit Morne Hotel
 Fodor's
 BlackBook
 Frommer's
 Lonely Planet
BP 14, Colombier 97095, St. Barthelemy
From $0/night
- Free Internet
 - Pool
 - Family Friendly
 - Free Parking
 - Kitchenette
 - Air Conditioning
 
 "Each of the modestly furnished but clean and freshly decorated, painted mountainside studios has a private balcony with panoramic views of the coastline." Full review
 "Big, clean rooms with full outdoor kitchens. Terraces have views toward St. Martin. Family-run hotel far away from the hustle of town." 
 "This is hardly the most luxurious or stylish lodging on an island that's legendary for its glamorous five-star hotels." Full review
 "High on the hill overlooking the northern coastline and small islands scattered offshore, Le P’tit Morne has a fantastic clutch of cliffside cottages with fully equipped kitchens." Full review