La Presqu'ilevsLes Mouettes
Both hotels are highly recommended by experts. Overall, Les Mouettes is preferred by most reviewers compared to La Presqu'ile. Les Mouettes is ranked #20 in St. Barth's with recommendations from 4 reviews such as BlackBook, Fodor's and Travel + Leisure.
La Presqu'ile
 Lonely Planet
Gustavia 97133, St. Barthelemy
From $0/night
 "Used primarily by ship crews and workers, St-Barth's cheapest lodging is ultra-basic, with no hot water, but occupies a central spot overlooking Gustavia's harbor." Full review
Les Mouettes
 Fodor's
 BlackBook
 Travel + Leisure
 Lonely Planet
Quartier Lorient, St. Jean 97133, St Barthelemy
From $0/night
- Kitchenette
 - Air Conditioning
 - Beach
 
 "This guesthouse offers clean, simply furnished, and economical bungalows that open directly onto the beach." Full review
 "Seven cozy cottages anchored right on Lorient Beach create a Gilligan's Island feel. Double beds and full kitchen make these abodes inviting for both a party posse or a family." 
 "Situated directly on Lorient Beach, this relatively affordable hotel makes up for its modest design with a prime location on the water." Full review
 "For budget-conscious beach lovers, it's hard to imagine a more appealing spot." Full review